Would you rather work from an office or remotely?
View all responses

Yes.
Well, actually, it depends on whether I’m speaking as a worker or as a manager.
Let me explain.
As a “worker”, I’m disabled. The UK benefits system has this phrase “fit to work”, and the benefits agency concurred that I don’t hit the mark.
The main reason for this is mobility. I’m including balance in this. So the agency’s rationale was that it was not possible for me to move safely around a workplace. The keyword there is safely, and it’s true – I still lose my balance and end up on my arse, periodically.
Now, there are some things I can do. I can type, as you can see. I do so with one finger, two at a push.
And I can think.
Contrast this to before I was disabled. I used to get up at 6am to get the train up to London, where I performed IT for a series of banks. Often that was leading people, which is where the “manager” viewpoint comes in. I operated as a consultant, so worked through my own company. So, technically, these banks were clients. I had to be flexible but it paid well and, since London is considered a “world capital” of IT, along with New York and maybe Sydney, it meant I was involved in some of the most exciting projects that were on the go, and with some of the best people in the business.
On the flip-side, I’d never get back home before 8pm and would do it all again the next day. I’d repeat this five days per week, then, certainly when my daughter was young, would plan a fun-filled weekend.
So speaking as a worker, I’d just settle for having that choice once again.
But speaking as a manager, I’m unequivocal. There was absolutely no doubt in my mind. I got far and away better results from my teams when we were all in the same room.
Incidentally, my (mostly-retired) friends who were also managers agree with me wholeheartedly on that last point. When it comes to kameradery, to being aware of what’s going on in the company beyond your own project, there is no substitute for bumping into someone at the coffee machine. You don’t get that with remote working.
