
You must all have heard of the Russell Brand conviction, right?
He was a strange character. Seemed to have no particular talent, but became a celebrity nonetheless, and it now transpires, used this fame in order to take advantage of women.
In the first instance, there was a TV documentary in 2023. Several women alleged that Brand had abused his status to commit sexual assault and rape.
The documentary then spawned a police investigation, which ultimately led to Brand’s conviction last week. But this investigation involved complaints by different women to those featured in the documentary.
This weekend just gone, with the trial out of the way, one of the original women has stepped forward again. She says she was sixteen when Brand “orally raped” her. Brand, at this time, was thirty.
Now, the law in the UK is quite straightforward right now. Any form of consensual sex becomes legal over the age of 16, period. Non-consensual sex is illegal, period, as you’d expect. And separate from the age of consent, the age at which a person is deemed to be an adult is 18.
So this woman is wanting some kind of grooming offence. She’s not looking at changing the age of adulthood, so the new law would apply just to 16/17yos. She wants to make it illegal for a 16/17yo to have a relationship with a 30yo.
I assume “relationship” is just a pseudonym for sex. How else could one legally define “a relationship”?
I must admit, I’m nervous about this.
It’s not that I don’t think it’s weird for a 30yo to want to have a relationship with someone 16/17. I do. Most definitely. With a daughter of my own, I’ve met several 16/17yos (male and female) and for the most part, they are pretty gormless. Okay, I shouldn’t generalise, but I do think there’s a mental disjoint between someone that young and someone older.
But while I might think it weird, I wouldn’t be happy to convict someone because of what I happen to think.
Especially when, if the 16/17yo says “no”, then straight away we’re talking about offences like rape and sexual assault, which are already on the statute books.
So what’s this woman saying? She seems to be talking specifically about a 16/17yo who says “yes” to sex. That they should be protected from older people. That, at 16/17, they might not be able to act in their own best interests? So she wants the state to legislate to say what their best interests are?
I mean, that seems to be the long and short of it, and I just think that’s a slippery slope, that’s all. It’s one of those scenarios where my gut says no.
For example, the UK talks about lowering the voting age to 16. That is something which has actually been adopted for certain elections in Scotland and Wales.
But if we’re saying that 16/17yos might not act in their best interests, how can we trust them to cast a vote?
You know, any change we suggest might have benefits, but it will also have consequences. I hope people think them through properly so we are consistent.
